Cookies and Fudge, Made with Love!

Made to Order ~ Always Fresh

Life is short. Just eat the cookie!

About Us

Homemade Just for You


At Sarah's Cookie Cottage, we believe in cooking from scratch, just the way Grandma used to. We never use preservatives, and bake with organic, all-natural and non-GMO ingredients, when possible. All of our cookies are baked to order, so you can expect fresh from the oven goodness with every order. 

We love referrals


We believe the best compliment any business can receive is a referral. So if you love our homemade sweets, please  share us with your family and friends. Don't forget to tell them to let us know you sent them so we can say thanks with a special treat for the both of you.  

Loyalty Program


Here at Sarah's Cookie Cottage & Fudge in Arlington, we strive to win your heart and your business through delicious homemade sweets. So, to thank you for allowing us to continuously serve you, we want you to enjoy a treat on us!